Hersi Maths WhatsApp me

Understand · explore · practise

Comparing distributions in context

Compare location and spread with units and context, choose robust summaries, account for sample sizes and avoid unsupported claims about individuals, thresholds or causation.

Before you startMean, median, standard deviation, IQR, box plots and grouped diagrams.

01 / Make two supported comparisons

Describe location and spread in context.

State the statistic, compare its values, then interpret it in the variable’s units.

A summary describes the dataset; it does not guarantee every individual outcome.

For journey times, a lower median means a shorter typical journey in the median sense. A smaller IQR means the middle half is less spread out. Neither statement proves the service is always quicker or explains why the difference occurred.

What does the evidence support?Explore

A: median journey time 24 minutes, IQR 8 minutes. B: median 30 minutes, IQR 14 minutes.

A has a shorter median journey and a less spread-out middle half.

Supported. The medians and IQRs support these sample comparisons, not an ordering of every individual journey.

02 / Interpret the centre

Higher is not automatically better.

Route A has median journey time 24 minutes; route B has median 30 minutes.Worked example

A’s median is 6 minutes lower

Name the statistic and size of the difference.

Its typical journey time is shorter, using the median

Use the meaning of the variable.

We cannot say every A journey is shorter

The distributions may overlap.

01 · Test scores

Class A has mean score 62 and class B has mean 68 on the same test. Give a supported comparison.

Hint

Compare means in marks, not every student.

Worked solution

B’s mean score is 6 marks higher. This does not imply every B student outscored every A student.

02 · Error magnitudes

Two machines have median absolute errors 0.2 mm and 0.5 mm. Is the larger median preferable for accuracy?

Hint

Absolute error measures distance from the target.

Worked solution

No. The 0.2 mm median indicates a smaller typical absolute error. Context determines what a higher value means.

03 / Interpret variability precisely

Specify which part of the distribution is summarised.

03 · Journey variation

Route A has IQR 8 minutes; B has IQR 14 minutes. State a comparison.

Hint

IQR describes the middle half.

Worked solution

A’s middle half of journey times is less spread out by the IQR measure; its IQR is 6 minutes smaller. This does not describe the full range.

04 · SD and units

Two delivery samples have SDs 3 hours and 5 hours. Compare variability.

Hint

Use SD in the original units.

Worked solution

The sample with SD 3 hours has smaller variability by the SD measure. Variance would have units hours squared.

04 / Choose useful summaries

Outliers can make robust summaries helpful.

Median and IQR focus on order and the middle half.

Mean and SD use all numerical observations and can be strongly affected by extreme values.

05 · A very high income

Most incomes are moderate but a few are extremely high. Why might median and IQR help describe a typical income and central spread?

Hint

They are less sensitive to the sizes of extreme observations.

Worked solution

They describe the centre and middle half without the high values pulling the mean upward as strongly. The extreme incomes still matter and should not be deleted merely to simplify the summary.

06 · Is a pairing compulsory?

Must the mean always be reported only with SD, never with a range or quartiles?

Hint

Useful standard pairings are not universal bans.

Worked solution

No. Mean/SD and median/IQR are common informative pairings, but additional summaries can answer different questions. Explain the purpose and limitations of the chosen statistics.

05 / Normalise unequal samples

Use proportions for relative comparisons.

07 · Counts or percentages

A sample of 80 has 20 journeys over 40 minutes. Another of 200 has 40. Which sample has the higher proportion?

Hint

20/80 compared with 40/200.

Worked solution

First sample: 25%; second: 20%. The second has more long journeys in absolute count but a lower sample proportion.

08 · Histogram comparison

Why can raw-count histogram areas mislead when comparing samples of very different sizes?

Hint

A larger sample can make all counts larger.

Worked solution

Relative-frequency areas, using each sample’s own total, permit proportional comparisons. Use consistent classes and units, or explicitly account for differences.

06 / Separate summaries from shape

The same summaries can hide different distributions.

Watch: same mean and SD, different tail counts

Pause, replay or seek freely. The notes explain the same idea and stay in view.

09 · A threshold count

Does mean 20 and SD 4 determine the percentage above 24?

Hint

No distributional shape has been stated.

Worked solution

No. Many distributions have that mean and SD but different threshold counts. Do not silently assume a normal distribution.

10 · Same median and IQR

Two samples share median 10 and IQR 4. Must their ranges, means and sample sizes be equal?

Hint

The two summaries contain limited information.

Worked solution

No. They can differ in tail values, overall range, mean, size and detailed shape.

07 / Keep conclusions within the study

An association is not a causal explanation.

11 · Tutoring comparison

One self-selected group has a higher mean score than another. Does this alone establish that a teaching method caused the difference?

Hint

Consider prior attainment, selection and other factors.

Worked solution

No. The comparison describes these samples. Without an appropriate design, confounding and selection offer alternative explanations.

12 · Generalising

A convenience sample of commuters has a low median journey time. Can it establish the median for all commuters?

Hint

Check representativeness before generalising.

Worked solution

No. Sampling method, coverage, timing and sample size affect what can be inferred. A precise sample calculation does not remove sampling bias.

08 / Write a defensible conclusion

Statistic, comparison, context, limitation.

Compare an appropriate centre and spread, attach units and interpret their meaning. Use percentages for unequal sample sizes. State what is observed and what requires assumptions or stronger evidence.

Section 1 of 8 · Make two supported comparisons